Faith, Death, and Redemption in Hazbin Hotel
An interpretive look at how Vivienne Medrano’s infernal musical becomes a mirror for faith, belief, and the longing to be saved.
SPOILERS AHEAD FOR HAZBIN HOTEL
Vivienne Medrano’s Hazbin Hotel (2024–) is a musical, ultraviolent, and visually chaotic depiction of Hell. Yet beneath the humor and flamboyant excess lies something much more deliberate: a meditation on faith, salvation, and the paradox of redemption. As Season 2, Episode 3 deepens the lore of the series, it begins to feel as if the hotel itself—Charlie’s grand experiment to “redeem” souls and send them to Heaven—operates less like a rehabilitation project and more like a religion. It runs on faith, ritual, and unproven promises of transcendence. In that sense, Charlie’s “Happy Hotel” might be read as a mirror of Christianity, a belief system whose redemptive logic only validates itself after death.
Faith Without Proof: The Economy of Belief
From the very beginning, Hazbin Hotel presents a paradox. Charlie insists that sinners can be redeemed, but no one has ever actually seen redemption take place. Her dream depends entirely on faith—an unprovable belief that Heaven will accept those who have changed. The citizens of Hell are right to doubt her; the angels’ annual “exterminations” make clear that Heaven’s system is built on punishment, not mercy.
It is hard not to notice how closely this structure resembles Christian faith. Both depend on belief in an unseen reward. Salvation, in both worlds, is something promised but never confirmed in life. Charlie’s one piece of “evidence,” that she heard from Emily that Sir Pentious made it to Heaven (and potentially just a rumour), functions like apocrypha: a story sustained only by her conviction. Her followers believe in her not because she has proof, but because she radiates hope.
In that way, Charlie’s faith feels familiar. It is a faith that exists without evidence, a conviction that meaning and redemption can exist even when all signs suggest otherwise.
The Death Cult Parallel
Logic dictates that Sir Pentious died by sacrificing himself for others, thus, if redemption in Hazbin Hotel only seems takes effect after death, then Charlie’s project can be read as a commentary on how belief systems often operate. No one in Hell can see the outcome of her work, only trust that it will matter when they are gone. Redemption is deferred; death becomes the test of faith.
This echoes the structure of many religious traditions, where ultimate truth and reward are postponed beyond mortal life. Salvation is promised, but only confirmed after the believer dies. The result is a kind of “death faith,” in which life is shaped around an unprovable hope for what comes next.
Charlie’s followers, in this sense, are converts. They reform themselves in the belief that their death might bring transcendence. Like many real-world religions, the project offers comfort, meaning, and a reason to strive—but no proof. It is a theology of trust in the unseen.
Charlie as Christ and as Heresy
Charlie’s position within this framework recalls Christ imagery almost too clearly to be accidental. She is the daughter of Lucifer, which makes her both divine and fallen, Heavenly by origin and Hellish by context. That duality mirrors Christ’s own paradox of being both human and divine, a savior who walks among the condemned.
But where Jesus preached a message that came from God, Charlie’s message comes from the Devil’s lineage. Her gospel is one of mercy for those Heaven has already judged. That inversion makes her a heretical messiah: a redeemer whose authority does not come from above, but from below.
If Jesus taught salvation through faith in divine grace, Charlie preaches salvation through the possibility of personal change. Her message replaces obedience with compassion, divine law with empathy. She becomes both Christ and Antichrist, a redeemer who challenges the system rather than serving it.
It is easy to imagine that if Heaven represents institutional religion, Charlie’s project is the reformation or perhaps the rebellion—within it.
Heaven as Bureaucracy, Hell as Humanity
The show’s depiction of Heaven and Hell makes this inversion even sharper. Heaven, instead of being pure and merciful, appears bureaucratic and militarized. Its angels carry out exterminations with administrative precision, their righteousness maintained through violence and quotas.
Hell, by contrast, is messy, emotional, and painfully human. Its sinners are cruel but relatable, each clinging to some fragment of longing or pain. The contrast flips the usual hierarchy: Heaven is order without compassion, and Hell becomes chaos full of heart.
Charlie’s hotel exists somewhere between those extremes. It is a grassroots experiment in mercy, a small community trying to create meaning in a world that has written them off. The hotel feels like an underground church, its rituals improvised and its faith sustained through fellowship. In that light, Charlie’s theology becomes a kind of resistance; redemption as defiance, forgiveness as rebellion against a system that offers none.
Faith, Futility, and the Absurd
By Season 2, the show leans into the absurdity of Charlie’s vision. Her insistence that redemption is possible begins to sound almost delusional (even though we the audience know of Sir Pentious’ assentation), yet that delusion is the very source of her power. Running a hotel in Hell for souls who cannot truly leave borders on existential satire, but it also captures something deeply human.
Faith, in both religion and storytelling, often survives because it refuses logic. Charlie’s hope persists not because it makes sense, but because the alternative is despair. Her mission, however hopeless, becomes a way to keep meaning alive in a system designed to erase it.
The characters around her stay not because they are convinced, but because they want to believe. In a world ruled by cynicism and punishment, belief itself becomes an act of resistance. Charlie’s optimism, irrational as it is, starts to look like the only real form of grace in Hell.
The Infernal Gospel: Biblical Echoes in the Cast
Looking closer, the ensemble of Hazbin Hotel resembles an inverted Gospel story. Each main character echoes a biblical archetype, though reshaped through the show’s irreverent lens.
Charlie Morningstar → Jesus Christ
The heretic messiah who redeems the damned not to serve Heaven, but to prove that its judgment was wrong. She is Hell’s version of Christ, born from rebellion rather than divinity.Alastor → Judas Iscariot
The betrayer who stands closest to the savior. He joins the mission out of curiosity, not faith, his support a façade. Like Judas, he is both the skeptic and the catalyst who may ultimately force Charlie’s faith to evolve.Vaggie → Peter
The loyal but fearful disciple, devoted yet full of doubt. She believes in Charlie while trying to protect her from her own idealism.Angel Dust → Mary Magdalene
The outcast convert, a sinner marked by love and shame, whose story embodies the true possibility of redemption.Lucifer → God (Inverted)
The distant creator, once divine but now fallen, watching from afar as his child attempts to build a new covenant out of ruin.Lilith → The Holy Spirit or Sophia
The unseen presence whose absence feels like divine wisdom lost, the quiet echo of maternal faith that the world has forgotten.Husk → Doubting Thomas
The weary skeptic who needs proof before he can believe, yet carries the potential for faith hidden under his cynicism.Niffty → The Innocent Convert
A small embodiment of unthinking joy, the naïve believer who clings to chaotic innocence simply because someone must.Heaven’s Exterminators → Pharisees and Rome
The agents of order who mistake violence for virtue, guardians of a divine bureaucracy that has forgotten mercy.
Taken together, these figures form what could be called a Gospel of Hell: a reimagined scripture where faith grows out of rebellion, and salvation arises not despite sin, but through it. In this reading, Heaven becomes the empire and Hell becomes the last refuge of humanity. God’s daughter, not His son, offers salvation.
Alastor’s Judas-like presence gives this myth its turning point. Without betrayal, there is no crucifixion, and without crucifixion, no resurrection. His corruption may be the test that transforms Charlie’s idealism into something stronger and more mature—a gospel forged in opposition, not innocence.
Simply Put: The Gospel of the Damned
Seen this way, Hazbin Hotel becomes a meditation on belief itself. It mirrors the logic of Christianity—a faith built on unprovable promises of salvation after death—but reframes it through compassion and defiance. Charlie’s hotel functions as a church for the lost, its mission a song of impossible hope. By tying redemption to death, the series reveals how both Heaven’s order and Hell’s chaos depend on faith to sustain themselves.
If Christianity can be read as a faith sanctified by hope beyond life, then Hazbin Hotel is its infernal reflection, a place where the damned reinvent belief in the ashes of failure. That, perhaps, is the show’s deepest truth: in the most hopeless world imaginable, Charlie dares to keep believing that even eternal punishment cannot destroy the possibility of redemption.
Table of Contents
